The adoption of IFRS 9, Financial Instruments, marks a significant shift for the Pakistani banking and non-banking finance sector, moving from the old “incurred loss” (IL) model under IAS 39 to a more proactive, “Expected Credit Loss” (ECL) model. This transition, mandated by the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) and the Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP), fundamentally changes how financial institutions recognize and measure potential credit losses.
1. The Core Change: From ‘Too Late’ to ‘Forward-Looking’
The central change is the timing of loss recognition:
- Under IAS 39 (Incurred Loss): Banks could only book a loss once there was objective evidence that a loss event had already occurred. This was often criticized as being “too little, too late,” especially during the 2008 global financial crisis, as it delayed the provisioning until credit risk had fully materialized.
- Under IFRS 9 (Expected Credit Loss): Banks must now recognize an allowance for credit losses based on expected future losses at all times. This requires a forward-looking assessment, incorporating current economic conditions and reasonable and supportable forecasts (macroeconomic scenarios) into the credit risk models.
This new approach forces banks to be more prudent, acknowledging potential losses much earlier in the life of a loan.
2. The Three-Stage Impairment Model
IFRS 9 uses a three-stage approach to measure ECL, which directly impacts the amount of loan loss provisioning:
- Stage 1: 12-Month ECL:
- Applies to assets where the credit risk has not significantly increased since initial recognition.
- The provision is calculated based on expected losses that could occur over the next 12 months.
- Stage 2: Lifetime ECL (Non-Credit-Impaired):
- Applies when the credit risk has significantly increased since initial recognition, but the loan is not yet credit-impaired (defaulted).
- The provision shifts to lifetime expected credit losses, which is a much higher allowance.
- Stage 3: Lifetime ECL (Credit-Impaired):
- Applies to assets that are considered credit-impaired or defaulted (similar to the old ‘incurred loss’ definition).
- The provision remains at lifetime expected credit losses.
The trigger for moving from Stage 1 to Stage 2 (Significant Increase in Credit Risk or SICR) is a key area requiring significant judgment and new modeling by Pakistani banks.
3. Anticipated Impacts on Pakistani Banks
The implementation of IFRS 9 brings several key implications for the financial statements and operations of banks in Pakistan:
- Higher and Earlier Provisions: Most international studies indicated an increase in initial loan loss provisions (often 10% to 50% globally) upon transition. While local studies may vary, the standard aims for earlier and likely higher recognition of provisions compared to IAS 39.
- Increased Volatility in Provisions: Provisions will now be more sensitive to changes in economic forecasts (e.g., inflation, GDP growth, unemployment). A pessimistic macroeconomic outlook can lead to a sudden and sharp increase in ECL, resulting in greater volatility in the income statement.
- Impact on Regulatory Capital: Since higher loan loss provisions reduce profits, they consequently decrease retained earnings and Common Equity Tier 1 (CET1) capital. The SBP has provided detailed application instructions and revised implementation timelines (e.g., major banks started on January 1, 2023, and others on January 1, 2024) to manage this capital impact and ensure a smooth transition.
- Data and IT System Overhaul: The new models require significantly more granular data, including historical credit risk data and forward-looking macroeconomic data, often at the level of individual financial instruments. This necessitates substantial investment in new IT systems, modeling capabilities, and internal controls, posing a significant operational challenge.
- Increased Management Judgment: The calculation of ECL and the determination of SICR are highly principle-based and involve considerable management judgment, requiring robust internal governance and documentation to ensure consistency and prevent manipulation.
4. Conclusion:
IFRS 9 in Pakistan represents a fundamental transformation in risk management and financial reporting for the Pakistani financial sector. By shifting to the ECL model, the standard promotes greater prudence, transparency, and earlier recognition of credit risk, ultimately enhancing the resilience of the banking system to economic shocks. Successfully navigating this change requires not only technical accounting compliance but also a deep integration of risk management, finance, and IT functions to build and maintain the sophisticated models required by the new standard.
Adopting IFRS 9 is more than an accounting change — it’s a strategic transformation that demands robust data systems, predictive modeling, and regulatory alignment.
At FineIT, we specialize in helping banks and financial institutions across Pakistan implement IFRS 9 with confidence. Our team of experts provides end-to-end support — from ECL model design and validation to data architecture, system automation, and SBP compliance reporting.
📊 Let FineIT help you simplify IFRS 9 compliance and strengthen your financial risk framework.
👉 Contact us today to learn how we can support your IFRS 9 journey.